It’s Not a Bad Idea. It’s a Bad Fit.

I’m a hunch-er. Shoulders up by my ears, head out front like a turtle checking the weather.

So I did what any sensible computer forensic investigator would do. I decided to invent a posture-correcting t-shirt. A cross-hatch pattern across the back would pull my shoulders into line. I called it Posture T.

Here’s what I knew about manufacturing: squat.

So, my mom sewed a prototype. Then sewed it again. Then again. (Thanks, Mom.) Every version taught me the same lesson: I had no clue how to make this, let alone scale it.

It ate up months. Hours every day that should’ve gone into the successful business I already had were going into a long shot idea that I was trying to spark.

The jacket in the window

You know that jacket. The mannequin looks incredible, and every third person on the street is wearing it. You buy it, get home, and it fits like a tarp.

The jacket isn’t bad. It’s just not suited for you.

Shiny objects work the same way. They look great on somebody. But that doesn’t mean they’re a fit.

Three questions before you commit

Here’s how Posture T would’ve gone:

  • Does this solve a critical problem for my best customers? My investigation clients couldn’t have cared less about their posture. Their businesses were in crisis.
  • Does it fit what we’re already good at? It had nothing to do with the forensic investigation work I was already doing (and doing pretty well, mind you). Plus, I’d never touched manufacturing. That’s a different business, not an add-on.
  • Can we make money doing it? I couldn’t even make the shirt. (Ridiculous, I know.)

Zero for three. If I’d asked these questions, I’d have known in an afternoon that I should walk away. Posture T would have landed where all business distractions belong: the land of “Thank God I didn’t do that.”

The burger joint that keeps saying no

In-N-Out Burger could have franchised. They could have gone public. They could have stuffed the menu with cranberry salads or whatever was trending that year.

Yet, they didn’t. The menu is still basically burgers, fries, and shakes, the same as it’s been since the beginning. They never franchised or took the company public, partly because rapid growth threatened the quality customers came for. The owner, Lynsi Snyder, has said the only reason to do either would be for quick money, and that’s not a reason she’ll accept.

The result? Roughly 400 locations and $1.8 billion in revenue in 2022. Nobody said no to growth. They said no to the wrong growth.

I know. A billion-dollar burger chain isn’t your business, and it isn’t mine. But the filter works at any size.

Curious is good. Distracted is expensive.

Stay curious. Play around with that new thing a little. Just don’t let it pull hours away from the business that’s making money for you. The boring thing that pays the bills isn’t the enemy. It’s your pathway to profit.

Back to the shirt

I spent months trying to make a shirt that worked for a problem none of my customers had. The idea wasn’t the problem. Skipping the qualifying questions was.

This week, pick the new idea you keep thinking about and answer those three questions in writing.  If even one is a no, that means the whole idea is a no-go. If you have all three as a yes, then and only then do you have a potential add-on. 

You’ve got this.

-Mike

I am here to help you with your idea. I have a monthly call as part of my Better Call Mike program. We will work together on our live group call and see if you have something that fits like a glove, or, you know, fits like a tarp.

 

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *